The Happiest Hour

The Happiest Hour

Date April 05, 2016
Time 3:30 PM EDT

Reservations

This session has concluded.

The Meaty Details

The Happiest Hour's cleverly-named 'The Happiest Burger' has been dubbed by NY Eater as the "Love Child of Shake Shack and In-N-Out...a double-pattied, expertly seasoned, dripping with American cheese, canyon-deep with flavor from onion confit and a sauce touched with mustard." People from Yelp have also described the burger, but people from Yelp are idiots. We're going to try this bad boy ourselves, taking the big table and doing the dirty deed with this dastardly, double-pattied delight.

Overall Verdict

Consolidated scores from 16 ratings

6.2 /10
The Details
Taste
6.4 /10
Texture
6.2 /10
Toppings
6.3 /10
Sides
6.8 /10
Value
4.6 /10
Venue ambiance
5.8 /10
Harmoniousness
7.2 /10
Burger Club seal
Andrew's Review
"Earlier this month, a select crew of us took a test drive in our shiny new cattle-Cadillac of a website, winding up at The Happiest Hour in the West Village. There, we hoped to find a no-frills, affordable burger in a jovial, congenial atmosphere. Sadly, like Moses and the Golden Fleece, we were misled. First things first, this is a perfectly nice burger - many commented that it’s more or less a higher-quality Big Mac (or In-N-Out style burg for my western brethren), but there’s no denying that it’s pleasing for the taste buds. Would you seek it out? Unlikely. Would you fight an innocent child to the death for just one sumptuous bite? Probably not. But would you gratefully slam one down after a night on the town? Undoubtedly. That said, this was not a night on the town. This was Burger Club. We are an epicurean and discerning lot. We are also lovers of value, and here was where our troubles began. A $12 burger is fine, but to not include fries (another $4 - though admittedly exceptional) is a brash and dangerous move. Then, to charge $9 for a 12 ounce beer and $16 for wine/cocktails is to spit in the face of all that’s still decent in this world. Said one commenter: “What is this, Per Se?” No…no it was not Per Se. Unless Per Se has become an Alien Mothership Breeding Ground for the most Brotastic Broligarchy of Broverlords...a literal Brotanical garden of the Broletariat…a Holy Broman Empire…let’s just say the ambiance took a hit as well."

Member Reviews

April 05, 2016
6.9 /10
Taste
6.0 /10
Texture
6.0 /10
Toppings
8.0 /10
Sides
7.0 /10
Value
5.0 /10
Venue
7.0 /10
Harmony
9.0 /10
5.3 /10

Love the 1$/ounce beers!

Taste
6.0 /10
Texture
5.0 /10
Toppings
6.0 /10
Sides
7.0 /10
Value
4.0 /10
Venue
2.0 /10
Harmony
7.0 /10
April 05, 2016
6.1 /10

A glorified Big Mac, not that that's a bad thing. Overall a solid grease burger/fries combo but the $8/$9 beer price point hurt me deep.

And, call me a Luddite, but after all these fancy website upgrades we don't have the ease of manually adding an Andrew-as-a-person score like we did in the paper and pencil days. I don't trust this.

Taste
8.0 /10
Texture
8.0 /10
Toppings
7.0 /10
Sides
6.0 /10
Value
3.0 /10
Venue
3.0 /10
Harmony
8.0 /10
April 05, 2016
7.3 /10

Andrew Is such an incredible person it defies belief.

Taste
8.0 /10
Texture
8.0 /10
Toppings
9.0 /10
Sides
6.0 /10
Value
7.0 /10
Venue
5.0 /10
Harmony
8.0 /10
April 05, 2016
5.6 /10

I loved this place mostly because all of my friends (and the burgers) were here. Now it's time to go home!

Taste
2.0 /10
Texture
8.0 /10
Toppings
1.0 /10
Sides
5.0 /10
Value
3.0 /10
Venue
10.0 /10
Harmony
10.0 /10
April 05, 2016
8.3 /10

How do you get better than sweet Andrew? Not possible xoxo

Taste
8.0 /10
Texture
8.0 /10
Toppings
8.0 /10
Sides
10.0 /10
Value
8.0 /10
Venue
8.0 /10
Harmony
8.0 /10
April 05, 2016
6.3 /10

Andrew, as a person, again, another race to the bottom as far as humans go.

I like our server who was easy going and seemed cool with a table of a million people. And her curls had a prefect amount of bounce.

The shoestring fries were a treat but I am morally opposed to not having sides included in the overall price of burger. What is this? Per Se?

The hamburger left a lot to be desired. I had recently planned a run to end at Five Guys and found that burger much more satisfying.

Taste
6.0 /10
Texture
5.0 /10
Toppings
6.0 /10
Sides
9.0 /10
Value
3.0 /10
Venue
8.0 /10
Harmony
7.0 /10
5.0 /10

This was decent but I would not seek out this burger. It's salty and has a McDonald's like texture. However if I was hammered and eating it I would think it's great as fast food fix .

Taste
5.0 /10
Texture
5.0 /10
Toppings
5.0 /10
Sides
5.0 /10
Value
5.0 /10
Venue
5.0 /10
Harmony
5.0 /10
6.6 /10

Great place! The drinks and fries are top notch but not a truly memorable burger. I wouldn't hesitate to order it again, but not something to come here for specifically. The drinks and fries however...

Taste
6.0 /10
Texture
5.0 /10
Toppings
7.0 /10
Sides
9.0 /10
Value
4.0 /10
Venue
8.0 /10
Harmony
7.0 /10
4.7 /10

Andrew? Clever chap. Too bad really.

Taste
7.0 /10
Texture
5.0 /10
Toppings
3.0 /10
Sides
5.0 /10
Value
5.0 /10
Venue
2.0 /10
Harmony
6.0 /10